COLUMBUS, Ohio -- In the largest study of its kind to date, Ohio State University researchers have shown that the stress women experience after breast cancer diagnosis and surgery can weaken their immune response, based on at least three different biochemical indicators.
The findings, reported in the Jan 7, 1998 issue of the Journal of the National Cancer Institute, are the latest in a series of studies documenting the link between conditions of high stress and low immunity.
Barbara Andersen, professor of psychology and researcher with Ohio States Comprehensive Cancer Center and Institute of Behavioral Medicine Research, said the results were the strongest evidence shes seen of a stress-linked immune reduction in cancer patients.
Andersen and her colleagues studied 116 women who underwent surgery for stage II or stage III invasive breast cancer. Before the women began follow-up adjuvant therapy, they completed an extensive questionnaire intended to gauge their stress levels. Based on how they responded to the questionnaire, they were placed in either a high- or low-stress group.
Blood was drawn from women in both groups and tested for three different indicators of immune status. The first test measured the extent to which natural killer (NK) cells were breaking down. NK cells are essential components of the immune systems search for tumors and virally infected cells.
Andersens team also checked how well the NK cells responded to gamma interferon, a compound naturally produced by the body that enhances NK cell activity, as well as inhibiting replication of a virus.
The researchers then tested how well the womens T-lymphocytes -- white blood cells that are key to the immune response -- responded to two plant chemicals (PHA and Con-A), as well as to monoclonal antibodies.
Their analyses showed the following:
I think this is the most reliable effect Ive seen so far in any of the scientific literature, Andersen said. And its occurred in the largest stress and immunity study so far thats focused on cancer patients.
Andersen said this kind of study is very difficult to do.
We were literally recruiting women (into the study) on what they described as the worst day of their lives. Not only had they just had surgery but theyd also been told they had positive nodes (the cancer had spread to the patients lymphatic tissue), cutting their prospects for survival in half, Andersen said.
The new findings are the first real results from Andersens six-year, $4.2 million project. The study was funded by the National Institute of Mental Health and the Department of the Army. Initial grant support came from the American Cancer Society.
The study will eventually involve 235 breast cancer patients, Andersen said, and include additional testing of other immune system components. A comparable report citing changes in hormone levels key to immune response is expected later next year.
Andersen and her colleagues are also randomly assigning women in the study to one of two groups. The first will only be monitored and assessed for stress levels while women in the second group will be taught strategies for lowering their stress levels, improving their diets and increasing their exercise. At the end of six years, the researchers will compare the immune and endocrine responses, health and survival of women in both groups.
Other members of the research team included William Farrar, associate professor of surgery; Robert MacCallum, professor of psychology and preventive medicine; Ronald Glaser, professor of microbiology and immunology and of internal medicine; Deanna Golden-Kreutz, project coordinator; Leigh Ann Kutz, laboratory technician, and Mary Elizabeth Courtney, a research associate.
Contact: Barbara Andersen, (614) 292-4236; Andersen.firstname.lastname@example.org
Written by Earle Holland, (614) 292-8457; Holland.email@example.com
Return to the Research page
Return to the OSU Homepage
Go to the Research, Newsfeature, and Cancer Report Archive